We're comparing the Toyota Crown 2.5 Hybrid with the BMW 420i Gran Coupe M Sport to examine two interpretations of the modern fastback. One is an efficient, comfort-focused hybrid, while the other is a more dynamic, performance-oriented machine.
Related: What is the difference between a BMW 3 Series and a BMW 4 Series?
Fast Facts
Performance
The most significant divergence is in their driving philosophy. The Toyota Crown's hybrid powertrain is all about efficiency. Its 2.5-litre engine and electric motor provide ample power for daily driving and a smooth, quiet experience, especially in city traffic. Standard all-wheel drive provides confident traction in various conditions.
On the other hand, the BMW is for the driver who wants a more engaging experience. Its turbocharged petrol engine delivers strong torque from low down in the rev range, making for a responsive and lively feel. The rear-wheel-drive setup, with its M Sport suspension and a lower centre of gravity, promises a nimble and sporty ride. While both cars share an identical 0-100 km/h time, the BMW's significantly higher top speed of 235 km/h highlights its focus on outright performance.
Efficiency
Efficiency is a significant selling point in the modern automotive landscape, and here the Toyota Crown shines. Its hybrid system achieves a remarkable average fuel consumption of just 4.4 L/100km, making it a standout in its class. This efficiency saves money at the pump and contributes to lower CO2 emissions and a reduced emissions tax. The BMW's 6.5 L/100km is respectable for a performance-oriented petrol car, but it simply cannot match the hybrid’s frugal nature.
Design, Comfort, and Practicality
Both vehicles are fastbacks, but their proportions differ. The Crown is a physically larger car, longer, wider, and taller than the BMW. This translates to a more spacious and commanding presence on the road. The higher ride height offers a more "crossover-like" seating position, which some drivers may prefer. The BMW 4 Series Gran Coupe's design is lower and sleeker, giving it a more aggressive, athletic stance. While it's more compact, it offers more boot space with the seats up and significantly more when folded down.
Regarding interior features, the Crown offers a comprehensive list of standard amenities, including a panoramic sunroof and heated and ventilated front seats, enhancing the comfort and luxury experience. With its M Sport trim, the BMW provides a sporty, driver-focused cabin with high-quality materials and an extensive list of optional extras for personalisation, such as adaptive cruise control and a head-up display.
Verdict
The Crown Hybrid could be considered the pragmatic choice. It’s a larger, seemingly comfortable car emphasising fuel efficiency and space. It’s an ideal option for buyers who want a premium sedan experience with the cost-saving benefits of a hybrid powertrain, all-wheel drive and a practical interior. The 420i Gran Coupe is for the driver who values engagement and performance. Its handling is dynamic, its engine is punchy and it looks sporty. Still, It sacrifices a bit of practicality and efficiency in the name of dynamic driving.
