Answer
Jan 25, 2022 - 08:39 PM
Hi there!
These two cars are surprisingly closely-matched in most respects, so comparing them is a smart move. Let's see what's on offer:
1. The Kona is likely to return better fuel economy in the real world, because the VW's EA888 engine is known to be pretty thirsty in normal driving. Expect mid-8 l/100 km in conservative driving with the Hyundai, and mid-to-low 9 l/100 km with the VW, altough driving any one hard will increase that past the 12 l/100 km mark. Also remember that the VW will suffer extra driveline losses, due to its AWD system, so those parasitic energy losses will always consume extra fuel.
2. Provided that you don't get a T-Roc with its optional wheels (stick to the normal "Design" trim with 17-inchers), it should offer a more-comfortable ride than the Kona (which rolls on 18s as standard). The difference should be marginal, however, and may not be readily apparent in most driving conditions.
3. The VW is likely to be cheaper in the long run, simply because it shares a lot of its hardware with other VW Group cars. In contrast, TGDI Hyundais are still thin on the ground, probably making future repairs more expensive. They both have dual-clutch gearboxes, though, which are generally expensive to maintain and repair at high mileages.
4. Resale value would be a win for the VW, simply because it's a VW. Hyundai's core products (i20, Atos, Grand i10, Tucson) hold onto their value quite well, but their specialist cars tend to struggle in this regard.
5. Performance in the real world will be very similar, because they weigh roughly the same and have similar outputs. The VW may be quicker with a full load, however, because it has a substantial torque advantage.
6. Despite its rounded body shape, the Kona actually offers a larger luggage volume, whether with the rear seats up or down. It's much the same for the front seat occupants, although the Hyundai's rear seats are slightly more cramped (due to its sloping roofline).
So, between these two, we'd rather go for the Kona: it has more advantages than disadvantages, will be cheaper to insure, and match or better the T-Roc in most respects. You might also want to consider a used BMW X2 - they depreciate quite steeply, so you should be able to get a late-model used one for similar money to the Hyundai or VW.
Hope this helps!
The AskAutoTrader Team
Add New Comment