Answer
Nov 21, 2021 - 10:22 PM
Hi there
WIth your specific set of requirements, we'd recommend against the BMW 120d (or any BMW, for that matter): while the engine/gearbox combination is pretty reliable (given frequent servicing according to manufacturer's requirements), the rest of those cars can get pretty troublesome in the long run. We're talking about vacuum pump failures, coolant pump issues, drive belt pulleys packing it in, and plastic fittings and seals on the cooling system all known for being items that frequently need attention. In addition, the electronic systems on those cars are complex, and while they're generally quite durable, the chances are that any mishap in this area will be costly to remedy.
As far as the Golf TDI/GTD goes, the mehanical bits are bulletproof, although a DSG (automatic) is again not a good choice for long-term ownership peace-of-mind. If you do go for a Golf, ensure that it's a manual, and prepare yourself for occasional air intake clean-ups and likely turbo replacement as it ages.
We'd like to suggest something else that will suit your needs a fair bit better: Have a look at a Kia Sportage 2.0D, from this vast selection we have here on site. Their R4 2.0 diesels have a very good reputation for durability and affordable long-term maintenance, and whether you go for a manual or an auto, the drivetrain is also up for good long-term service. The auto is a bit slower, but much nicer to drive, so that's where our money would go. In addition, the SUV/crossover body style will easily deal with our rough road conditions, and there's so much loading space that you probably won't even need that trailer...
The same applies to Hyundai ix35s from similar vintage, so if you prefer the curvy Hyundai style, you can have a similarly good buy from the Kia's sister brand. Lastly, your idea of steering clear of premium brands is a good one: there's a good reason why ageing premium cars are priced as cheaply as they are, and that's because running costs become prohibitive.
Hope this helps!
The AskAutoTrader Team


Add New Comment