Answer
Sep 12, 2021 - 11:57 PM
Hi there
The need for more power is within most of us, so it's understandable that you'd want more than the 66 kW in your Polo...
From your wish list as stated, it's worth remembering that the Audi A3 and VW Golf are essentially the same cars with different trimmings, so the same downsides apply to them all. It's also a good idea to avoid these DSG transmissions if you're planning to keep the car for a longer term - especially so in the case of the 7-speed dry clutch units employed in lower-powered VWs/Audis.
However, the rumours about the 1.4TSI engine (used in both the Audi A3 and Golf) are based upon issues which pertained mostly to older models. Starting around 2014, software updates alleviated most of the premature wear issues that plagued earlier examples of this engine, so a 2015-on example should prove relatively trouble-free if the factory maintenance schedule is followed to the letter.
Sadly, the stories about the Astra's long-term maintenance are likely to be true - while aftersales backup is still fully available for these cars, the GM-sourced components used in the Astra (and its concurrent Adam/Corsa models) can be brutally expensive and quite difficult to obtain, so long-term ownership may prove to be problematic. They are lovely cars, though, although the manual gearboxes in those cars are also known for being a bit fragile.
May we suggest something completely out of the ordinary here? How about you go test drive a late-model Hyundai Accent hatchback: It looks quite sporty, is very nice to drive, quicker than the 66 kW Polo, and very economical. Parts availability is first-rate and often interchangeable with many other Hyundai/Kia models, so servicing and maintenance should be quite hassle-free as well.
Alternatively, you may want to consider a late-model Kia Cerato 2.0 (either manual or auto), which could be had with coupé or sedan body styles. Once again, it should be pain-free to own in the longer term.
Hope this helps!
The AskAutoTrader Team
Add New Comment