Answer
Apr 22, 2019 - 06:12 PM
Hi there
Glad to have been of assitance in the past, so let's see how well we can advise you this time around.
First things first: yes, a VW GTI of any description is a high theft- and hijack risk, which not only has implications on the insurance premiums, but also on your son's personal safety.
That leaves you with three alternatives: the Peugeot 208 GTi (which is a low crime-risk car and performs pretty well as well); or a Renault Clio RS (which is great fun to drive, and equally low-risk in terms of crime); or a Fiesta ST. The problem with the French cars is durability and maintenance costs - the RS is generally fragile due to being so highly strung, and the GTi uses the problematic "Prince" 1.6T engine, which often racks up stupendous repair costs in a short time.
Of these three, the Fiesta ST would be the preferred choice. It's reasonable on maintenance, it's a low crime risk car (except for the recent spate of break-in due to a weak door lock design, but the Internet already has a variety of fixes for that), and it's pretty decent on fuel as well. It's also great fun to drive, plenty quick, and (provided your son isn't too broad in the hips) pretty comfortable as well. Alternatively, a low-mileage Focus ST can give him stonking performance and lots of fun, even if it is rather thirsty at the pumps.
So, in order of preference:
Fiesta ST
Focus ST
Renault Clio RS
Peugeot 208 GTi
Hope this list makes your choice easier!
The AskAutoTrader Team


Add New Comment