Answer
Jul 14, 2018 - 11:55 PM
Hi there
Thank you for your nicely detailed question - the more information we have, the better our advise will be!
Let's take your questions one by one, in the order in which you asked them:
1. The most reliable, comfortable and fuel-efficient one would be the newest one with the least fancy add-ons and the most cabin space. This means that a new Golf 1.0T Comfortline R-Line (current list price: R338 750) will meet this requirement the best. That 1.0T engine is suberbly frugal, and with the change left over from your R350 000 budget cap (with the balloon payment), you can tick the option box to get the panoramic sunroof added.
2. Unfortunately, you're still a very young driver, which will make insurance problematic due to driving inexperience. This means that you'll need to select a car with a low insurance risk (lower performance and lower theft risk). Again, in this regard, the Golf 1.0T TSI will be the easiest on your pocket: BMWs are notoriously expensive to insure even at the best of times (because they're seen as high-performance cars), and the Polo is a high-risk car as far as the insurance companies are concerned.
3. Mileage is a bit of a tricky question: a young car (in years) with higher mileage will generally have travelled longer distances, and will have spent more time time on the freeway, which will have put less strain on clutches, mountings and the engine itself, than if it were used for shorter distances. Read more on this topic on this article: https://www.autotrader.co.za/car-news... , where we explain this in greater depth.
4. Balloon payments are seldom a good idea, but if it means that you can get a much nicer car, which you would want to keep for a longer time, it's a useful mechanism to qualify for finance. At a 30% residual value, it also won't cause too much of a dent in your pocket in the end, as you can simply re-finance the outstanding balance at the end and simply drive the car for a few extra years. Alternatively, the car will likely be worth more than the residual value (especially at a 30% residual), so you could then simply sell the car and settle the balloon from that sale. It doesn't make a lot of financial sense, however, as you will most likely end up paying up to twice the car's new value by the time all payments are settled. As with everything, there are pros and cons to each approach.
5. For your needs, the Golf will be the best buy, and the BMW will be the worst, for one simple reason: The BMW will be clean outside of its maintenance plan before you've paid it off, which could leave you exposed to substantial repair- and maintenance costs at a time when you might not be able to afford them. Meanwhile, the Golf will still have some of its maintenance plan left, and it's cheaper to repair and insure in your case (new driver). The Polo sits in the middle: similar running costs to the Golf, but less comfortable and probably more expensive to insure.
6. Again, you would be able to keep the Golf for the longest time.
7. Yet again, the Golf wins on this requirement.
Hope this helps, and happy motoring!
The AskAutoTrader Team


Add New Comment